How We Score Cigars: The KCS Explained
Every cigar we review carries a Kaufmann Cigar Score (KCS) — but a number means nothing without a method. So here is ours, in the open.
What the KCS measures
The score is built from a small set of weighted dimensions:
- Construction — draw, burn, ash, and consistency from light to nub.
- Flavor — depth, clarity, and how the profile evolves across thirds.
- Balance — whether strength, body, and aroma pull together or fight.
- Experience — the whole greater (or lesser) than its parts.
Calibration cigars
A score is only meaningful against a fixed reference. We keep a set of calibration cigars — known, repeatable smokes — and re-taste them regularly so the scale doesn't drift over time.
What it is not
The KCS is not for sale and not influenced by brands. No manufacturer pays for a score or sees it before publication. It is editorial judgment, shown openly.
New calibration notes and scoring updates will appear here on the BLOG.